ENSURING PATIENT SAFETY: A Closer Look at Restraints in Hospitals

Oct 25, 20234 min read

Updated: Oct 27, 2023

In the realm of healthcare, patient safety, and well-being are paramount concerns that guide the practices of medical professionals and institutions. One aspect that has garnered both attention and scrutiny is the use of restraints in hospitals. With the recent closure of the Hillview Hospital in Ebbw Vale, Blaenau Gwent (article here: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-66458773 ), we are taking a look at patient safety during restraints. As this is the second closure in the last few months, we feel it’s vitally important to talk about the legality and people’s safety, staff, and patients alike.

In Wales, the rest of the UK, and in other parts of the world, the application of restraints on patients is a complex and sensitive issue that requires careful consideration and ethical evaluation. This blog post delves into the topic of restraints in hospitals in Wales/UK, exploring the reasons for their use, guidelines that govern their application, potential benefits, and the ethical dimensions involved.

Understanding Restraints:

Restraints in a medical context refer to any physical or chemical methods used to restrict a patient's movement or behavior. These interventions are generally implemented when a patient poses a risk to themselves or others due to their medical condition or behavior. Restraints can take various forms, such as physical hands-on, devices like straps, cuffs, or vests, as well as sedative medications. While the intention behind their use is to ensure patient safety and prevent harm, the appropriateness and necessity of their application must be carefully evaluated. Your first protocol needs to be Prioritizing Communication and De-escalation: Essential Strategies in Restraint Situations (Read this post here - Coming Soon), and this is paramount.

Reasons for Restraint Usage:

Restraints are typically employed for several reasons, including:

Preventing self-harm: Patients who are agitated, confused, or suffering from certain mental health conditions might unintentionally harm themselves, requiring restraint to protect them from injury.
Protecting healthcare professionals: Restraints might be necessary to shield medical staff from patients who become combative or aggressive due to their medical condition or altered mental state.
Maintaining medical interventions: In some cases, restraints are used to ensure patients do not remove life-saving medical devices or interfere with treatments, such as intravenous lines or ventilators.

Guidelines and Regulations:

In Wales, as in the broader UK, the use of restraints is governed by strict guidelines to ensure patient safety and dignity. The Mental Capacity Act 2005 and the Human Rights Act 1998 provide a legal framework that outlines the circumstances under which restraints can be used and the procedures that must be followed. The primary principle is that restraints should only be used when all other less restrictive options have been exhausted, and their use should be proportionate to the risk presented by the patient's condition.

Balancing Benefits and Risks:

While the use of restraints can offer benefits in terms of preventing harm and maintaining medical interventions, there are inherent risks and ethical considerations. Prolonged restraint usage can lead to physical discomfort, psychological distress, and even medical complications such as pressure ulcers or impaired circulation. Therefore, healthcare providers must carefully weigh the potential benefits against these risks, always striving to find the least restrictive means of ensuring patient safety.

Ethical Considerations:

The ethical dimensions of using restraints in hospitals are multifaceted. On one hand, healthcare professionals have a duty to protect their patients from harm. On the other hand, patients have the right to autonomy, dignity, and the least restrictive treatment possible. Striking a balance between these principles requires transparent communication with patients or their families, obtaining informed consent when possible, and involving them in decisions related to restraint usage whenever their mental capacity allows.

Pain Compliance:

The use of restraints in healthcare settings is a contentious issue, often necessitated by concerns for patient safety and well-being. One aspect of restraint application that draws attention and debate is the concept of pain compliance. Pain compliance involves inducing discomfort or pain to compel an individual to comply with instructions or immobilization. In the context of medical restraints, the use of pain to ensure patient compliance raises complex ethical and practical questions. This article delves into the concept of pain compliance in restraints, exploring its rationale, potential benefits, ethical considerations, and alternative approaches. Breakaway & Restraint Specialists believe that this should be included in the PMVA training of your staff with the emphasis of it being the absolute last, and we want to state that again, the absolute last resort and only used when all else failed (de-escalation, etc.) and life or limb is at risk. We will explore this more in another blog post (Coming Soon)

Restraints in Hospitals, Care Homes, and wherever they are required in Wales, UK, and indeed globally, are a topic that demands careful attention due to their potential impact on patient well-being and autonomy. The judicious use of restraints, guided by legal frameworks, ethical considerations, and best practices, is crucial to maintaining patient safety while upholding their rights and dignity. As medical knowledge evolves and societal attitudes toward patient care continue to evolve, healthcare professionals must remain vigilant in their commitment to providing safe and respectful treatment to all patients.

We advise that you select a training provider that has a great understanding when it comes to restraints. We at BRS Ltd feel that restraints are a part of the training your staff requires to ensure that they and the people they are looking after remain safe and you can provide your best service possible. We believe that we provide just such training, so Contact Us to talk about and book your next PMVA training HERE or simply book training now:

Book PMVA Training Now